A trans woman suggested trans people needed better messaging and she was attacked as a bad 'cis ally'

(AP Photo/Elise Amendola, File)

You may remember the name Brianna Wu. Brianna is a game designer who became well know nearly a decade ago as one of the people at the center of gamergate, along with Anita Sarkeesian. Wu also ran for congress in 2018 and lost. Wu was generally believed to be a trans woman though she refused to comment on that for reasons she explained back in 2015:

Advertisement

Every single day, I have Gamergaters writing to call me transgender. Somewhere along the way, it became something they all seem to believe when the truth is I’ve never commented on it.

…anyone familiar with the subject knows there are many, many shades to being transgender! There are intersex people, there are non-binary people, there are deep stealth people. Ultimately, being transgender is a private, very serious medical issue that needs to be addressed as early in life as possible. I don’t think it’s helpful to anyone involved to treat it like a litmus test, where a person must come out publicly…

I choose to not respond, because nothing I can say in response to this accomplishes anything worthwhile. And it’s my suggestion to others to not buy into transphobia by responding. It encourages something that should be deeply private to become a witchhunt.

So, jump forward to this week and Wu tweeted something which really upset a lot of trans activists. The tweets have since been deleted but screenshots were made before that happened.

That sounds like a comment about messaging but the context for these remarks apparently involved whether or not trans people should have to demonstrate some kind of persistent gender dysphoria before they medically transition. Wu essentially said yes, mocking the idea that gender hormones should be given out as over-the-counter (OTC) medicine.

Advertisement

It’s not explicit but it’s safe to assume that all of this applies to children. In other words, if a 14-year-old boy decides he’s a girl he should have access to drugs and surgery without any kind of mental health check to make sure there aren’t other issues that could be impacting such a life-altering decision. Any sort of barriers to drugs and surgery for anyone is considered insulting to trans people (by some).

So that brings us to this article recapping the argument. It’s headlined “A Certain Cis ‘Ally’ is Being Dragged By Trans Twitter. Here’s Why.” The cis ally in question is Brianna Wu.

The Internet is a strange place to live, and yet I live there and so do all my friends. Honestly, where else are we supposed to live? This country hates trans people and is also on fire.

It’s also where we consistently get bullied, harassed, and harangued for speaking out against our own genocide. Sometimes, even the folks who call themselves allies are part of this painful cycle.

Exhibit A: Brianna Wu, a longtime trans Twitter staple who recently stepped in sh*t for implying that trans folks should “prove” dysphoria in order to fight Republican hatred and harassment.

Advertisement

The rest of the article is a bunch of tweets bashing Brianna Wu as a know-nothing leading up to this tweet which has since been deleted.

Here’s his later admission that he knows nothing about Brianna Wu.

Anyway, there are people who remember her and even her name before it was Brianna Wu.

If you’ve been around a while following politics then you’ve probably seen what happens when a Black Republican says something conservative and a bunch of people on the left immediately jump in to say he’s not really black. Well, this is the same dynamic but with a trans person. If you don’t toe the line, you get canceled. That’s just how the left works these days.

Advertisement

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Trending on HotAir Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Ed Morrissey 10:00 PM | November 22, 2024
Advertisement
Advertisement