Rather than play chicken with Joe Biden’s progressive spend-o-rama, NBC News reports, Senate Democrats will, um … play chicken for the second time on its federal takeover of elections. So … they’re trading one game of chicken for another? What’s the popular definition of insanity again?
NBC News: Senate expected to shelve Build Back Better bill, moving forward aggressively now on voting rights
— Jesse Rodriguez (@JesseRodriguez) December 15, 2021
BIG NEWS: Schumer is likely to push a vote on the Build Back Better plan until next year, according to four sources familiar with the leaders' plans. w/ @JulieNBCNews
He doesn't have the votes as Manchin remains noncommittal
1/
— Leigh Ann Caldwell (@LACaldwellDC) December 15, 2021
Joe Biden and Chuck Schumer planned to negotiate more with Joe Manchin yesterday and today. Can we presume that it didn’t go well? Nancy Pelosi certainly didn’t sound happy about the talks:
Pelosi rejects calls to pass stand-alone child tax credit since expansion is set to expire at year’s end. She said CTC is “important leverage” on BBB, and says she doesn’t want to “let anyone off the hook.” Yet Manchin has made clear to Biden he has concerns w CTC, per sources
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) December 15, 2021
Talks between Manchin and Biden are NOT going well on Build Back Better, per source familiar with talks. A huge sticking point: the Child Tax Credit. Manchin wants it cut. Source says he wants to “zero it out.” They are “very far apart,” source says.
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) December 15, 2021
Talk about insanity. This is the same “leverage” that Pelosi used to tie up the bipartisan infrastructure bill until Democrats took a beating in the elections last month. Now she’s leveraging children in order to force a vote on the same bill. That’s desperation indeed.
Apparently, Henry Olsen was more prescient than we knew. And perhaps so was I in comparing this situation to the collapse of SB1, the so-called “voting rights” bill that died on the vine last year because of opposition within the Democratic caucus and the filibuster. Schumer’s apparently attempting to fix the latter problem today:
Schumer met with Manchin, Kaine, King and Tester this morning to discuss possible rules changes to pass elections reform legislation, according to a source familiar with discussion
— Burgess Everett (@burgessev) December 15, 2021
I excerpted my May review of the filibuster situation that led to the collapse on SB1 in the earlier post, but I’ll repeat it here too:
The Post mentions that Democrats are frustrated that Manchin won’t overturn the filibuster to eliminate that need for engagement, but that’s also old news and Manchin’s not the only obstacle there either. Kyrsten Sinema has been even more opposed than Manchin to a change or elimination of the filibuster, and her Arizona colleague Mark Kelly belatedly (and somewhat ambiguously) chimed in to support Sinema. Progressives have been attacking Manchin and Sinema as “racists” ever since, which needless to say hasn’t wooed either of them off that position.
Insanity might put it mildly. This got tanked when Joe Biden enjoyed widespread popularity and high job approvals. With inflation raging and voters objecting to Biden’s performance and the direction he’s taking, why try now to pass another partisan bill on non-priorities for voters? Schumer should be focusing on a targeted Democratic response to inflation that might allow his caucus to reconnect to voters that they have clearly alienated. Instead, he’s choosing to do a remake of his greatest faceplants of 2021.
What about the BBB now? If this really does get punted into 2022, it’s all but dead on arrival. Democrats won’t want to take up the spending aspects of this while inflation rages and budget gimmicks keep getting exposed while simultaneously campaign for the midterms. Once the child tax credits come to an end, Congress will have to restart them rather than merely extend them in the manner that the BBB would have done, too. It’s practically the worst of all worlds, brought by leadership that vastly oversold its capabilities while failing to do the work necessary on a rational agenda that could pass in an evenly split Beltway.
Update: This should be obvious, but …
This kills any virtually any hope of getting the bill done by Christmas as Schumer had hoped. Biden and Manchin not close to a deal
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) December 15, 2021
I don’t think they’ll get any closer in 2022 either.
Update: Across the aisle, Josh Marshall calls this a “joke”:
If this is true, it's a joke. They don't have the votes for any voting rights bill. So this simply means shelving BBB. Period. https://t.co/6taG10KKZj
— Josh Marshall (@joshtpm) December 15, 2021
Exactly. Schumer would have been better off just sending the Senate home.
Update: So far Manchin’s still quiet about these developments, but Punchbowl’s John Bresnahan reports that he was privately telling colleagues that he would oppose BBB:
NEW – @Sen_JoeManchin was overheard on Senate floor in past vote series saying he was a no on motion to proceed to BBB, per source familiar
— John Bresnahan (@bresreports) December 15, 2021
Update: ‘Nuf said:
I hate to say "I told you so," but … no, wait, I love to say "I told you so."https://t.co/DOOApQSDDM https://t.co/UzHOlQPpcu
— Ed Morrissey (@EdMorrissey) December 15, 2021
Update: Manchin wasn’t so much a “no” as much as a “what the hell are we voting on,” Bresnahan updates:
/2 MANCHIN just called to say this is incorrect. Manchin said the conversation on the floor focused on “We don’t have the bill text yet, it hasn’t been vetted, the minority hasn’t seen it.” Manchin said the conversation wasn’t on whether he was yes or no on motion to proceed
— John Bresnahan (@bresreports) December 15, 2021
Well, yeah, that was another problem Schumer had.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member